Host C 4 Grandchildren 8
Both/And Logic Needed
1--The conclusion first, in the form of a haiku:
‘Both not both the one
And the other and both the
One and the other’
2—The problem: Luther’s question @A. D. 1517 was ‘How can a just God save a sinner
such as I?’ The answer: Jesus Christ died for you. (Justification by faith.) Our
question today @A. D. 2026 in the minds of many is ‘How can an all-good and
all-powerful God do seemingly horrible things, including sending some with
Death and Hell into the lake of fire for eternal conscious torture?’
The answer is a—Both/And Logic and b—Not explaining, but
believing, teaching and confessing. This c—Avoids errors such as denying ‘The
Bondage of the Will’ and affirming Dr. Day’s view that eventually all will be
saved—that torture is not eternal but for the purpose of inducing repentance
(if I understand correctly).
3—Some information about ‘logic’. Russell’s and Whitehead’s ‘Principia
Mathematica’ aims at completeness, and has
5 operators. These 5 are: and, or, not, if then, if and only if. A
Harvard scholar (if I remember correctly) said that these 5 could be derived
fron one: ‘not both the one and the other’. BUT WE BELIEVE, TEACH, AND CONFESS
FROM THE CHRISTIAN CREEDS ‘BOTH THE ONE AND THE OTHER. That is, Jesus Christ is
both very God of very God, and very Man of very Man. God is both 3 and 1.
4—Proof. There are 3
classical methods of proof. These are non-contradiction, correspondence, and
comprehensiveness. Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle takes care of
correspondence, for it holds that one cannot know both the velocity and
position of an electron at the same time. Also see Schroedinger. Goedel’s
Incompleteness Proof take care of non-contradiction, in that it shows that any
axiomatic system (such as ‘Principia Mathematica’) in incomplete—Well-Formed Formulas
(truth statements) exist which cannot be derived from the axioms. That leaves
comprehensiveness.
5—What do I know. My work memorizing Goedel is 60 years
past. A younger, better mind is needed to produce a logic of ‘both/and’ which
is similar to ‘Principia Mathematica’. Or I could be all wrong, but I don’t
think so. I await better work than I have produced, though I think that
believing, teaching, and confessing is better than trying to explain at this
time.

